Skip navigation
Favorites
Sign up to follow your favorites on all your devices.
Sign up
Odds by

On Friday, former Jaguars (now Commanders) kicker Brandon McManus and the Jaguars were sued for an alleged incident that occurred on the team flight to London during the 2023 season.

The NFL says this about the case: “We are aware of the matter but will decline comment.”

Sometimes, the NFL will acknowledge that a matter has triggered a review under the Personal Conduct Policy. Sometimes, the NFL declines comment. Regardless, it will be impossible for the NFL to do nothing about it.

McManus, through his lawyer, has denied any wrongdoing.

The Jaguars, who initially declined comment, issued the following statement on Monday night to ESPN.com: “We’re aware of the complaint, and we acknowledge the significance of the claims. As we continue to look into the matter, it bears emphasizing that we insist on an organization built by people who represent our community and game with the highest character and class.”

Such insistence is hardly foolproof, as evidenced by the fact that a former employee embezzled more than $22 million from right under the team’s nose.

In this case, the person facing the accusations no longer works for the Jaguars. Their bigger concern is the claim that the team failed to properly supervise McManus and that the team failed to provide a safe environment for the flight attendants.

But, hey, at least the head coach was on the plane — unlike the head coach who opted not to fly back with the team from a game in Cincinnati early in the 2021 season.


Commanders kicker Brandon McManus has been accused of sexual assault by two flight attendants on the plane that took his former team, the Jaguars, to London during the 2023 season. McManus, through his lawyer, has denied the allegations.

“To be clear,” attorney Brett R. Gallaway said (via Sam Fortier of the Washington Post), “these are absolutely fictitious and demonstrably false allegations made as part of a campaign to defame and disparage a talented and well-respected NFL player. We intend to aggressively defend Brandon’s rights and integrity and clear his name by showing what these claims truly are — an extortion attempt.”

Generally speaking, few if any civil defendants ever hire a lawyer to tell the world on the heels of the filing of the lawsuit, “Yep, I did it.” In this case, the denial is strong and sweeping and stretches beyond merely saying it didn’t happen to supplying an extortion motive to two different people, and their counsel.

If it’s made up, the fact will bear that out. Now that a lawsuit has been filed, both sides will have a chance to prove their case. The plaintiffs will tell their story. McManus will tell his. Witnesses will help move the needle one way or the other. Barring a settlement, a jury will decide who’s telling the truth, under the low standard of preponderance of the evidence/more likely than not.

The suggestion that it’s an extortion attempt raises the question of whether the plaintiffs previously attempted to secure payment from McManus in settlement of the claims. That’s what happened with the person accusing Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott of sexual assault. Prescott and his lawyers opted for the ultra-aggressive move of suing the alleged victim and her lawyers.

If McManus previously had been put on notice of the claim, the next question becomes whether he disclosed it, to the Jaguars or the Commanders or the NFL. On this point, the Personal Conduct Policy contains a clear and unambiguous requirement: “Clubs and players are obligated to promptly report any matter that comes to their attention (through, for example, victim or witness reports, law enforcement, civil litigation, or media reports) that may constitute a violation of this Policy.”

If McManus had been put on notice of the claims as an attempt to settle then before the lawsuit was filed (which is very common in the legal profession), he arguably had a duty to disclose it. If he knew about it before he signed a contract with the Commanders that has $1.5 million in guarantees at signing, that could potentially become a separate issue.

There are two different issues here. One, did he do what he’s accused of doing? Two, when he first became aware of the claim, did he promptly report it? It doesn’t matter if he denies it. It doesn’t matter if he truly didn’t do it. If, that is, the NFL will be enforcing the policy as written.

We know from experience that this isn’t something that consistently occurs.

So those are the issues for now. Did it happen? The court system will resolve that. Did McManus comply with the Personal Conduct Policy’s reporting requirement? That depends on facts that have not currently been disclosed.


The early stages of any situation involving allegations of misconduct consist of seeking comment from all relevant parties.

The current employer of kicker Brandon McManus — the Commanders — issued one. His employer at the time of the alleged incident, the Jaguars, had no comment.

We’ve asked the NFL for comment. Because McManus is and has been a member of the NFL Players Association’s Executive Committee since 2022, we requested comment from the NFLPA as well. Tge union had no comment.

It’s still expected that McManus will be issuing a comment on the matter tonight.

McManus was accused in a lawsuit filed on Friday of sexually assaulting two flight attendants on the team’s trip to London in 2023. The Jaguars also have been sued for failing to supervise McManus and failing to create a safe environment during the flight.


In most cases involving allegations of off-field misconduct against a player, the NFL’s mission is simple. Find the facts and, if the player violated the Personal Conduct Policy, drop the hammer.

As to the new allegations against former Jaguars (now Commanders) kicker Brandon McManus, the NFL is in a delicate spot. Because the Jaguars also have been sued for failing to supervise McManus and failing to create a safe environment on the flight to London, the team’s front-line defense will be, ideally, that McManus didn’t do anything wrong. Having the NFL take that position off the table will make it harder for the Jaguars to win in court.

So which will it be for 345 Park Avenue? Downplay the situation to help the Jaguars? Or aggressively investigate/discipline McManus and damn the legal torpedoes?

There’s a sweet spot in which the league finds that McManus did it in a way that absolves the Jaguars. That won’t be easy. And the effort will be fairly obvious, if it happens.

It’s a common problem for employers who face lawsuits because of the alleged misconduct of specific employees. There’s a strong temptation to circle the wagons and deny, deny, deny until the lawsuit is over, because the desire to protect the coffers supersedes whatever policies are in place to protect coworkers and third parties against misconduct.


The Commanders have issued a statement in response to the news that their kicker Brandon McManus has been sued by two women alleging he sexually assaulted them while playing for the Jaguars last year.

McManus is accused of assaulting two flight attendants during a team flight last September. The Jaguars have also been sued.

“Earlier today, we were made aware of the civil lawsuit filed on May 24 against Brandon McManus,” the Commanders said in a statement, via Nicki Jhabvala of the Washington Post. “We take allegations of this nature very seriously and are looking into the matter. We have been in communication with the League Office and Brandon’s representation, and will reserve further comment at this time.”

McManus, who signed with the Commanders in March, has not made any comment at this point, but ESPN’s initial report about the lawsuit said that he or his attorney is expected to make a statement at some point on Monday.