Dustin

May

May was drilled in the ankle by a batted ball off the bat of Dominic Smith in the opening inning, then remained in the game to face three additional hitters, so it was unclear initially if he was pulled due to injury or ineffectiveness. Either way, he was saddled with five runs on five hits and a pair of walks in just 2/3 of an inning. It sounds like he was able to avoid serious injury though, so he may be able to take his final turn in the Cardinals’ rotation before the All-Star break.

The Cardinals are skipping May’s turn due to lower back tightness with Andre Pallante taking the ball on regular rest against Miami on Saturday. The 28-year-old could probably use some extra rest after getting torched for six runs by the Royals his last time out following a one-hit shutout against the Padres back on June 15.

May struck out two, walked one, and allowed two homers in the abbreviated outing. His last start was a one-hit, complete-game masterpiece, and he had been on a roll dating back to mid-April. The Cardinals still found a way to win 12-10, so every pitcher got hit hard today. Despite the tough result, he’ll remain a streaming option next time out, at home against the Marlins.

May retired 18 consecutive batters before issuing a leadoff walk to Fernando Tatis Jr. to open the seventh inning, ending his perfect-game bid. He lost the no-hitter two batters later when Manny Machado sliced a one-out single into left field. He managed to complete eight innings on just 93 pitches and got the nod to return for the final frame, managing to set down Sung-Mun Song, Rodolfo Durán and Fernando Tatis Jr. on eight pitches to complete the shutout. He’s allowed three earned runs or fewer in four consecutive starts since May 27, lowering his ERA from 4.57 to 3.75 in the process. He’ll wrap up a two-start week with a home tilt against the Royals on Sunday.

May easily outdueled Freddy Peralta, and continues his hot run after a less-than-spectacular beginning to his campaign. The 28-year-old allowed only four hits — only one of those for extra bases — and he struck out six against a single free pass. May has looked the part and then some as of late, and his 4.21 ERA is more impressive when you consider it was 6.98 just a few outings ago. He’s worth streaming consideration next week against the Padres, with that start scheduled for Monday.

After entering the eighth with a no-hitter last time out against the Brewers, May struck out nine for a second straight outing tonight. Particularly impressive was that he threw his fastball 24 times with a 54 percent CSW and no hits allowed. Since giving up 13 runs in his first two starts, May has a 3.19 ERA and a 53/16 K/BB in 59 1/3 innings. We still wouldn’t typically trust him in mixed leagues, but he has some upside in a two-start week against the Mets and Twins next week.

May struck out nine in seven brilliant innings, but the eighth started with a Garrett Mitchell liner for a double with the Cardinals up by just one. A better left fielder than Bryan Torres might have caught the ball, but Torres had it go over his head. Luis Rengifo then put down a bunt and neither May nor third baseman Nolan Gorman attempted to make a play on it, turning the sacrifice into a hit. That ended May’s day, and the Brewers went on to score both runners with Jojo Romero on the mound. May fell to 3-6 despite having his most impressive outing since 2023. He’ll next face the Rangers on Tuesday.

May gave up an inside-the-park homer in the first, and a couple of singles led to another run in the fourth. That was it until the sixth, when he walked a batter with one out and gave up a double and two singles to end his afternoon. Fortunately, Gordon Graceffo was able to produce an inning-ending double play after taking over then. May struck out seven and allowed just three hard-hit balls in the game, though he surrendered six hits anyway. His ERA is back up to 5.00, but his peripherals are considerable better than that. The issue is that he has a .340 BABIP that far exceeds his career mark of .268. He should remain in the rotation and face Milwaukee next time out.

May also issued four free passes while striking out three in the ballgame. The Royals scratched out a pair of runs against him in the fourth inning, then added another on a ground out in the sixth that tied things up at 3-3. May got eight whiffs on 91 pitches on the night while posting a CSW of 23 percent. He’ll carry an underwhelming 4.81 ERA and 1.42 WHIP into Thursday’s tilt against the Pirates.

May took the defeat to fall to 3-4 with a 4.85 ERA, but that hardly tells the whole picture. Since giving up 13 runs in his first two outings, he’s turned in five quality starts in six tries, with his lone miss being an outing in which he allowed one run in 5 1/3 innings. He’ll work at home against the Royals next week. We still wouldn’t rate him as a good option in mixed leagues, but he’s definitely holding up his end of the bargain with the Cardinals so far.