If you were surprised by this one, we’d like to sell you the NIL rights to the Brooklyn Bridge.
Confirming the report that President Trump will be forming a commission on college sports, TheAthletic.com reports that former Alabama (and Michigan State and LSU and Miami Dolphins) coach Nick Saban will be named the commission’s co-chair.
The other co-chair is expected to be a “prominent businessman with deep ties to college athletics.”
The development should raise crimson flags for the players who have finally secured the freedoms that they had been wrongfully denied for years. Under the guise of fixing a problem that a corrupt system created, the commission undoubtedly will work to re-tilt the playing field in favor of the institutions — to the detriment of the kids who play the college sports that generate the revenue.
Saban’s point of view on the matter has been abundantly clear. Before resigning from his job as the head coach at Alabama, Saban said to himself, ‘Maybe this doesn’t work anymore, that the goals and aspirations are just different and that it’s all about how much money can I make as a college player?’”
The hypocrisy oozes from that attitude, given that Saban consistently made as much money as he could as a college and pro coach.
Before that, Saban complained that changes to the old ways, forced by the implosion of longstanding antitrust violations, threatened the sport’s parity. The truth was it threatened his ability to take advantage of the prior system, where there was little actual parity — and where Saban’s team dominated.
Saban wanted parity of resources because he knew that, under those rules, he had the recruiting skills to leverage parity of resources into disparity of results.
In 2023, Saban argued for an NFL-style set of rules. But the NFL’s rules were negotiated with a union operating as a multi-employer bargaining unit. That gives the NFL’s 32 independent businesses an antitrust exemption, allowing a draft and spending limits and rules regarding when and how a player can change teams.
The union approach is the best, and most fair, way to fix the current problem. The colleges, however, want to have it both ways, limiting player pay and mobility without having to deal with the rights and protections a union could negotiate. And Saban will soon have a key position of influence when it comes to attempting to jam through Congress a law that will give the colleges what they want: The ability to enact sweeping rules without having to grant the players the power of collective bargaining.
If it works, maybe Saban will get back into coaching again. Especially if the new rules don’t impact how much he can be paid, or when and how he can jump from one school to another.
President Trump signed 141 executive orders in the first 100 days of his second term. There’s another one in the pipeline that could provide a boost for most if not all of the NCAA’s 134 FBS schools.
The Wall Street Journal reports that the President is considering an executive order “that could increase scrutiny of the explosion in payments to college athletes since 2021.”
The seed apparently was planted during a Thursday meeting between the President and former Alabama coach Nick Saban, who quit coaching after the 2023 season due to his frustrations over (let’s call it what it is) his inability to continue stacking the deck with all the top players.
Per the report, Trump said he agreed with Saban and would look at crafting an executive order,” and “Trump told aides to begin studying what an order could say.”
While it has been popular for folks like Saban to whine about the impact of college football players finally getting real value for their skills, efforts, and sacrifices (and if you don’t think they make sacrifices, talk to Jordan Travis), why should any branch of government infringe on the ability of anyone to get paid?
Will there be an executive order limiting the amount of money CEOs can make? Actors? Musicians?
Will there be an executive order restricting the ability of the wealthy and connected to navigate the investment markets in a way that generates massive financial windfalls?
For anyone who believes in free enterprise, this is as free as enterprise gets. Businesses compete for the non-employee employees who will help them achieve their objectives. Those businesses that consistently make bad decisions will fail. Those businesses that consistently make good decisions will thrive. It’s the essence of the American way.
The current chaos in college football flows directly from decades of the various schools using the phony umbrella of the NCAA to limit what the players can receive. The legislative branch spoke on this matter more than 130 years ago, in creating the first antitrust laws. The judicial branch, spurred by long-overdue litigation challenging the entire system, has finally applied those laws to a set of artificial rules that has been an antitrust violation hiding in plain sight.
The moment arrived four years ago. Players, who were long denied the ability to get paid for what they bring to the college-football table, are feasting. The schools, which were able for far too long to exploit those players, are reeling.
Now, the executive branch is going to undo the work of the other two branches? For what purpose? Who wins, and who loses?
If Congress chooses to give college football a partial or full antitrust exemption, so be it. If the schools decide (as they should) to regard the non-employee employees as employees and embrace a nationwide union that would result in a labor deal that would result in bargaining on a wide range of rules aimed at striking a proper balance, so be it.
Regardless of whether the President is a Democrat, Republican, Independent, Libertarian, or Whig, the notion that any executive should or could restrict the ability of college football players to earn whatever someone will pay them would defy the three-branch system of government — and, until it is applied to others who (many are saying) are “making too much money,” would create a horrible double standard.
Ohio State running back TreVeyon Henderson recently visited the Cowboys and Panthers, Jordan Schultz of Fox Sports reports.
Henderson earlier in the month had a visit with the Bengals.
The Cowboys are expected to draft a running back to join a room with free agent signees Javonte Williams and Miles Sanders. The Panthers, who have Chuba Hubbard, Rico Dowdle and Raheem Blackshear at the top of their depth chart at the position, won’t have Jonathon Brooks this season after he tore the ACL in his right knee again.
The Bengals signed Samaje Perine to go with Chase Brown and Zack Moss.
Henderson ran 144 times for 1,016 yards and 10 touchdowns during the final of his four years at Ohio State. He also caught 27 passes for 284 yards and a touchdown.
Henderson scored 19 touchdowns as a freshman, but missed time with injuries in his other two seasons, playing a combined 18 games.
Running back TreVeyon Henderson helped Ohio State win the national title in January and he’ll be visiting a nearby team as part of his pre-draft process.
Jeremy Fowler of ESPN reports that Henderson will visit the Bengals this week. A report last week indicated Henderson’s Buckeye backfield mate Quinshon Judkins will also be meeting with the Bengals.
Henderson ran 144 times for 1,016 yards and 10 touchdowns during the last of his four years at Ohio State. He also scored 19 touchdowns as a freshman, but missed time with injuries in his other two seasons.
Chase Brown ran 229 times for 990 yards and seven touchdowns as the lead back for the Bengals in 2024. They signed Samaje Perine to go with Zack Moss as other options at the position.
Alabama quarterback Jalen Milroe had private workouts with the Saints and the Browns, Jordan Schultz of Fox Sports reports. Both teams are expected to select a quarterback at some point in the draft.
He met with key members of the Jets before his Pro Day last month, a day after the Steelers had dinner with him the night before his throwing session.
Milroe reportedly will attend the draft in Green Bay.
He could could go in the first round, but there’s a better chance he hears his name Day 2.
Milroe threw for 2,844 yards with 16 touchdowns and 11 interceptions last season, and he ran for another 726 yards and 20 scores. He was 21-6 as a starter, but only 9-4 this season with losses to Vanderbilt, Tennessee, Oklahoma and Michigan.