Skip navigation
Sign up to follow your favorites on all your devices.
Sign up

An alternate Premier League Team of the Year


during the Barclays Premier League match between Manchester City and Manchester United at Etihad Stadium on March 20, 2016 in Manchester, United Kingdom.

Michael Regan

It’s hard to argue with the PFA Premier League Team of the Year released Thursday.

Hard, but not impossible.

[ MORE: U.S. mid Gooch extends deal with Sunderland ]

If you missed it, the voted Best XI for the Premier League included four Spurs and four Foxes to go with West Ham’s Dimitri Payet, Manchester United’s David De Gea and Arsenal’s Hector Bellerin.

So rather than nitpick one or two spots, which is really easy, what if we argued for an entirely different XI, one that would certainly rival the winners.

Actual winners: Harry Kane and Jamie Vardy
Alternate take: Sergio Aguero and Romelu Lukaku

Everton v Aston Villa - Premier League

LIVERPOOL, ENGLAND - NOVEMBER 21: Romelu Lukaku of Everton celebrates scoring his team’s second goal during the Barclays Premier League match between Everton and Aston Villa at Goodison Park on November 21, 2015 in Liverpool, England. (Photo by Nigel Roddis/Getty Images)

Getty Images

Look, there’s little debate that both Kane and Vardy deserve their honors, but Aguero is having a historically productive year at Man City while Lukaku is setting Everton records with his striking boots. Lukaku was never going to get on the Team of the Year with Everton so low, but Aguero has a right to be peeved: He just may yet win the Golden Boot for a team possibly finishing third.

Winners: Dele Alli, Dimitri Payet, Riyad Mahrez, N’Golo Kante
Alternate take: Mesut Ozil, Ross Barkley, Eric Dier, Mousa Dembele


during the Barclays Premier League match between Liverpool and Tottenham Hotspur at Anfield on April 2, 2016 in Liverpool, England.

Michael Regan

Three of the four are irreplaceable on this list, but can we pour one out for Mesut Ozil here? The Arsenal midfielder had an incredible start to the season and has racked up 18 assists to go with 6 goals. I realize Dele Alli is young and English, but his numbers don’t measure up (10 goals, 9 assists).

As for the rest, Barkley might’ve cruised to a first half Team of the Season, but his offensive production has dipped considerably down the stretch. He had 6 goals and 7 assists on New Year’s Day. Since then, he’s added just two goals. Dier and Dembele are solid parts of Spurs’ run.

Were it not for table standing, we’d be begging you to consider Bournemouth’s Andrew Surman and Aston Villa’s Idrissa Gueye. If there’s any justice in the world, there will be a bidding war for the latter that helps Aston Villa start anew in the Championship.

Winners: Danny Rose, Toby Alderweireld, Wes Morgan, Hector Bellerin
Alternate take: Erik Pieters, Virgil van Dijk, Chris Smalling, Nathaniel Clyne

Leicester City v Southampton - Premier League

LEICESTER, ENGLAND - APRIL 03: Jamie Vardy of Leicester City and Virgil van Dijk of Southampton battle for the ball during the Barclays Premier League match between Leicester City and Southampton at The King Power Stadium on April 3, 2016 in Leicester, England. (Photo by Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images)

Getty Images

Center back might be the hardest position to pick in the entire league, as even with the four named between the real team and our selection you’re omitting Robert Huth and Jan Vertonghen amongst others. Pieters has been a veritable Ironman for Mark Hughes at Stoke, while Van Dijk would be the Premier League newcomer of the year -- if there were such an award -- if not for Kante. Smalling’s done well for United, while Clyne has been a bullet down the right side and looks well-suited for a Jurgen Klopp team.

Winner: David De Gea
Alternate take: Petr Cech

Arsenal v Swansea City - Premier League

LONDON, ENGLAND - MARCH 02: Petr Cech of Arsenal in action during the Barclays Premier League match between Arsenal and Swansea City at Emirates Stadium on March 2, 2016 in London, England. (Photo by Richard Heathcote/Getty Images)

Getty Images

With Fraser Forster and Jack Butland having missed large stretches of time, this would go down to Cech and Spurs’ Hugo Lloris. I hate making the choice, but I’m giving the edge to Cech because of a less impressive back line in front of him.

Follow @NicholasMendola