The case was filed on February 1, 2022. More than 27 months later, it’s in the federal appeals process on the question of whether and to what extent some of the claims will land in arbitration.
In recent months, the NFL (and several teams), former Dolphins coach and current Vikings defensive coordinator Brian Flores (along with Steve Wilks and Ray Horton), and a group of 12 law professors have filed lengthy briefs with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit on the arbitration issue.
The NFL’s brief was filed in early December. The Flores brief was submitted on July 11, and the brief on behalf of the independent law professors was filed on July 18.
The appeal focuses on the district court’s decision that Flores’s claims against the Broncos, Texans, Giants, and the NFL are not subject to the NFL’s internal arbitration system that puts final say in the hands of Commissioner Roger Goodell.
“To say Mr. Goodell is biased would be an understatement as: he is professionally and financially beholden to the NFL and its teams, he enjoys his job as NFL Commissioner — the pinnacle of power and prestige — at the leisure of NFL team owners, he is personally represented by the same attorneys representing Defendants, and he is paid tens of millions of dollars annually to act in their best interest,” Flores’s lawyers argue at the first page of their brief.
The final brief, for now, comes from a dozen “law professors and scholars who focus on dispute resolution.” They express concern that the potential outcome of the case, with the NFL permitted to control and resolve the claims made against it, “may undermine the equitable administration of arbitration and erode public confidence in arbitration.”
The appeals brings into focus the NFL’s long standing effort to force non-player employees to submit any claims to arbitration ultimately controlled by Goodell. The law professors argue that, if the NFL’s skewed, self-serving model is permitted to stand, other companies will do the same thing.
They’re absolutely right. It makes no sense for the person ultimately in charge of a given business to have the power to resolve disputes involving that business. No one should want to even be put in that position. Fair outcomes to spirited legal fights demand an independent party to ascertain the facts, consider the law, hear the arguments, and make a decision.
The mere fact that the NFL wants the ability to issue final, binding judgment as to disputes involving the various teams and/or the league office is a horrible look. It should be a P.R. disaster for the league, but few in the media ever explain in clear terms what a horrible look it is.
Hopefully, more will. Although life would be a lot easier if we all possessed total authority to resolve any and all arguments in which we were involved, no one should want that kind of power. Because it makes every outcome seem suspicious and, at some level, unfair.
Regardless of whether media (and, in turn, fans) wake up to the shameful way in which the NFL has handled its in-house arbitration procedures, here’s hoping the court system shuts down for good the NFL’s secret, rigged, kangaroo court. If not, it could soon become a staple of American business.
Before the draft, when the 49ers supposedly were considering a trade of receiver Brandon Aiyuk, there was a time when it seemed as if they would trade receiver Deebo Samuel instead.
The Steelers reportedly wanted Deebo, but the 49ers reportedly wanted more than the Steelers were willing to give.
With the 49ers now facing a formal trade request from Aiyuk, one potential path out of the maze would include trading Deebo and paying Aiyuk as the team’s WR1.
Frankly, Aiyuk performed like the team’s WR1 last year. Even though he had only 105 targets in 16 regular-season games last year, Deebo had only 89 in 15. As to receptions, Aiyuk had 75 for 1,342 yards. Deebo had 60 for 892.
And although Samuel helped lay the foundation for his current contract by enhancing receiving with running, he had only 37 carries in 2024.
Deebo, after demanding a trade and behaving as if he’d never play for the 49ers again, signed a three-year, $71.55 million extension. The new-money APY is $23.85 million. His salary for 2024 is $20.972 million.
Trading Samuel would trigger a cap charge of $6.65 million this year and $15.143 million next year. (If they’d traded him before the draft, they would have taken a cap hit of $21.793 million this year.)
So they could trade Deebo and pay Aiyuk and hope others (like rookie Ricky Pearsall) can fill the void. Or they could trade Aiyuk and hope others can fill the void.
Or they can take a hard line with Aiyuk and hope he shows up and that, when he does, he continues to be the guy he was last year.
49ers receiver Brandon Aiyuk recently asked for a trade. Before the draft, trade talks nevertheless happened.
Negotiations occurred not because Aiyuk wanted out, but because the 49ers invited his representatives to explore whether another team would pay Aiyuk what he wanted on a long-term deal.
At the time, the magic number was in the neighborhood of $28 million per year. That quite possibly has changed, given the market-shifting deal given by the Vikings to receiver Justin Jefferson.
Regardless, there were five teams, we’re told, who were ready to pay Aiyuk what he wanted before the draft. If they could also reach acceptable trade terms with the 49ers, he would have been traded.
That part didn’t happen. It’s unclear what the 49ers wanted at the time. They rejected an offer of a second-round pick from the Patriots. Other interested teams were, and potentially still are, the Steelers and Commanders.
A post-draft trade becomes problematic for the 49ers, unless someone can offer a current player who will help the 49ers win in 2024. If the best offer includes 2025 draft picks, the 49ers could be tempted to take a hard line with Aiyuk, requiring him to complete the final year of his 2020 first-round rookie deal and then possibly tagging and trading him after the season.
Much of what happens depends on how firm Aiyuk will be in his request for a trade. Will he hold out of training camp? Will he stay out deep into the regular season, showing up in time to get credit for 2024 and setting the stage for an exit in 2025?
Commanders rookie defensive tackle Johnny Newton isn’t ready to get on the field yet.
The team announced on Friday that Newton has been placed on the non-football injury list. Newton had foot surgery in January and then had another surgery to repair a Jones fracture after the Commanders drafted him in the second round in April.
Newton can be activated from the list at any point, but he will not be able to practice with the team at training camp until that happens.
Newton had 52 tackles, 8.5 tackles for loss, 7.5 sacks, a forced fumble, and four blocked kicks on his way to making the All-America team at Illinois last season.
Jason Wright has transitioned out of his role as Commanders president and is set to depart the organization by the end of the 2024 season, news that was first reported by the Washington Post.
Wright will now serve as a senior advisor to team owner Josh Harris, who bought the franchise last summer. He’ll primarily focus on the team’s search for a new stadium site and naming rights partner, while Harris begins his search for the next Commanders’ president.
“This feels like the right moment for me to explore my next leadership opportunity,” Wright told the Post in a statement. “I’m extremely grateful to my Commanders colleagues, our fans and this community for all that we have accomplished these past four years, and am looking forward to the start of a very successful season for the Burgundy and Gold.”
“Jason has made a remarkable impact on the Commanders organization since he joined four years ago,” Harris said in a statement to the Post. “He stepped in at a time of immense challenge and has led this organization through an incredible transformation that set that stage for everything that is to come. I am extremely grateful to Jason for his partnership to me and the rest of the ownership group over the past year. His guidance has been invaluable and his leadership has helped reshape our culture.”
According to the report, Wright’s previous contract was set to expire next month. The team is also prepared to support Wright departing should he find another position before the end of the season.
Wright joined the organization in Aug. 2020 when the franchise was known as the Washington Football Team. He was the first Black team president in league history.
Wright was also reportedly a finalist to be the next Packers CEO, but Green Bay elected to promote from within and announced Ed Policy will take over in the role next summer.